Wednesday, November 6, 2013

Week 9 Recap: Notre Dame 38, Navy 34


Last Saturday, the Fighting Irish of Notre Dame squeaked out a tough 38-34 victory over the Navy Midshipmen to improve to 7-2 on the season. Well, that was certainly more interesting and intense than I thought it would be. Based on how well the Irish have played against Navy and the other service academies since losing to the Midshipmen in 2010, I thought Notre Dame would cruise to their seventh win of the season. Boy, I was wrong. Hats off to the Naval academy, they played a nearly flawless game and gave the Irish everything they had.

When George Atkinson III split the middle of the Navy defense for a 41-yard touchdown run with 12:12 left in the first quarter, the rout seemed to be underway. But instead, Navy responded with 9-play, 56 yard touchdown drive to tie the score at 7-7. From there, a seesaw battle would begin with nine lead changes before the game ended in a 38-34 score. Notre Dame scored the winning touchdown with 3:47 left in the game on a 1-yard touchdown run by Tarean Folston. Navy was driving to set up a potential game-winning score, but their hopes ended when the Irish defense sniffed out a reverse on a 4th and 4 from the Notre Dame 31-yard line.

The Positives

1. The Irish offense. Against an inferior defensive opponent, the Irish offense enjoyed a very productive and efficient day. Notre Dame tallied 506 yards of total offense with 264 of those yards coming on the ground. The Irish ran 56 plays on the afternoon, good for a 9.03 average yards per play. As a result, the Irish only faced five third downs and just one fourth down situation. In addition, Notre Dame racked up 25 first downs, meaning that 44.6% of the plays called resulted in a first down. That is a tremendous percentage and shows how effective the offense was when they had the ball.

2. Tarean Folston’s breakout game. Tarean Folston officially arrived in South Bend by accounting for 140 of the 264 rushing yards. Folston carried the ball 18 times, and may have cemented himself as Notre Dame’s featured running back for the remainder of the season. The true freshman was explosive by attacking his holes and making quick-hard cuts when necessary. This was a performance that the Irish were looking for out of one of their running backs all season, and one they desperately needed as they look to close out the season against some tougher defenses.

3. Another close win. It might not be good for the hearts of Irish fans, but Notre Dame has developed a knack for winning close games. The four-point victory on Saturday marked the 10th straight win decided by a touchdown or less, a streak that ties Brian Kelly with Knute Rockne for the second-longest streak in school history. The record is currently 12, set by Elmer Layden. The ability to win close games proves that Brian Kelly has successfully changed the culture of this program. Since Lou Holtz left, Notre Dame seemed to be on the losing side of many close games, but Brian Kelly has instilled a confidence in his players that they believe they can win every game.

The Negatives

1. Irish defense had no answer for the Navy option. As good as the Irish offense was on Saturday, the defense was just as bad. Maybe I shouldn’t say that, because the Navy offense deserves a ton of credit. Navy ran 79 plays that totaled 419 yards, good for a 5.30 average yards per play. With the steady attack, Navy was able to control the ball for 37:36, while committing no turnovers and no penalties. It was a nearly flawless display of offense. Navy’s execution was paramount because of their ability to get off the ball quickly. There were numerous times where I thought either the Navy offensive line or running backs were moving early, but they were not. That’s how fast they were getting to their blocks and holes. As a result, the Notre Dame defense was not getting to their assignments quickly enough. Fortunately, the Irish offense was dominant in the second half and the defense made a play when they needed to secure the victory.

2. Turnovers, Penalties, and Time of Possession. As mentioned above, Notre Dame lost to Navy in all three of these critical areas. Navy had the ball for more than 15 minutes than the Irish did, and that really had an effect on how well the Navy offense played. The Notre Dame defense was on the field an awful lot, and they did not have much time to recover between possessions with the Irish offense scoring so quickly. Notre Dame also had a minus two turnover margin and committed five penalties for 55 yards. The fact that Navy won all three of these phases, shows how well of a game they play.

3. Early missed opportunities. With the scored tied 7-7, Notre Dame drove 67 yards in seven plays that led to a field goal to give them a 10-7 lead. While that is fine, Notre Dame missed a golden opportunity to take a 14-7 lead when Tommy Rees’ throw sailed on Troy Niklas on a 3rd and 3 from the 8-yard line. Niklas was open, but the throw had to be high in order to get it over the underneath coverage. Rees put a little too much air under it, and the ball bounced off of Niklas’ extended hand. It was a pass that could have been converted, and one that both Rees and Niklas probably wish they could have back. After taking a 10-7 lead, the Notre Dame defense forced a Navy punt and had a chance to take a two-score lead. Once again, Notre Dame was driving, but that drive ended on an interception when T.J. Jones slipped making his cut on a deep-in route. If Jones doesn’t slip, the play would have likely resulted in a reception setting up a potential field goal or touchdown. In the end, Notre Dame was only up 10-7, when they could have been up 21-7. If that occurs, the rest of the game may have been a much different story with Navy traveling by two scores.

-Eric Tichelbaut

Follow me on Twitter @etichel07

No comments: